Date: 05 Jul 2015 14:52 Title: Dual Edged (Perseverance) - Maren O'Connor
It's very true - there are shades of meaning and this is why we, as writers, are well-served by reading a lot and continually editing and paying attention to word choice. You're good at this; I like to think I'm improving at it. I think it's a part of what gives away more experience versus less.
For Maren, technically 'stubborn' isn't an insult. Yet it seems to feel that way to her all the same. It's the part where her gifts are, in some ways, denigrated.
Date: 05 Jul 2015 02:52 Title: Dual Edged (Perseverance) - Maren O'Connor
Yes. Agree with her on all points here; people call me "stubborn" far more than they call me "tenacious" and "stubborn" is often used in a negative way. Stubborness isn't a horrible thing, it has it's benefits (as Maren no doubt proves) but I get where she's coming from.
Date: 02 Jul 2015 13:52 Title: Scientific Notation (Distance) - Adele Oyugo
I see you went with a downbeat story for this prompt. Adele's pain is very real and well-realized.
I think this is where Trek in particular is fictional. A lot of the magical stuff is, too, but the nuts and bolts of distance are truly wrong. Even if you hit Einstein upside the head and blow his theory away, space is still FAR. And it seems like only VOY and ENT really got that and tried to show it at all. I recognize that the demands of weekly television don't allow for showing the reality, but even a ship traveling at 1000 times the speed of light is going to take a month or so to traverse 100 light-years, and 400 or so light-years is still on the same galactic arm that we're on. Hence her comprehension that the distance is hard to fathom? Right on target.
Difficult and haunting; Adele is hurting in a way that's very relatable.
Me? Downbeat? Never. (Heh.)
Voyager was definitely the best, IMO, about showing the insane distances involved with this kind of travel. At max cruising velocity, they could travel 1000 light years in a YEAR. Hence the 70-something year optimistic estimate for getting home.
In Tesseract, I try to keep the distance in perspective, even though the QSD means that under certain circumstances, they can cross the galaxy in a month. But they're not doing that every day. The insane energy levels and computational power needed to do that means that it's good for very large jumps and emergency escapes, and not much else -- it's just not worth the resources (they're not utilizing dark matter drives just yet ;-) ), and besides, their ability to see the universe around them is limited at that effective velocity ... meaning it's hard to really "explore" at slipstream speed. So they're at "regular" warp a lot of the time, and sometimes, they have to weigh whether the use of the QSD is worth it.
As for Adele, she's an empath who basically just lost the other half of her soul. Yes, she's hurting, and in some ways, she always will be.
Thanks for the review!
Date: 02 Jul 2015 11:23 Title: Scientific Notation (Distance) - Adele Oyugo
Truth spoken here in such few short words. You can definitely hear how thankful she is that Ken isn't a Borg, but you can hear her missing him all the same (as well she should).
If he had been taken instead of killed, there's no way Adele would still be in Starfleet, except maybe on a suicide mission of vengeance. I can't imagine the assimilation of one's Imzadi would do anything but ruin a Betazoid. But yes, she missed him desperately ... and still does. There's a reason she hasn't married again in all this time.
Date: 01 Jul 2015 20:58 Title: Secondhand Emotion (Melancholy) - Taran Madar
Man, Taran has a mess of a backstory much like my own Betazoid. The two definitely need to share a drink at some point in the future and exchange some tales. Striking pience, and a great look into a character that often gets forgotten about in the Tess universe.
Well, she hasn't been forgotten so much as ... uh, replaced, at least in her core importance to the story. ;-) But yes, Taran and Felicia have more in common than their taste in human men. :)
Date: 01 Jul 2015 15:30 Title: Secondhand Emotion (Melancholy) - Taran Madar
This is the 'magical' Star Trek characteristic that I am least interested in having for myself. I agree with Taran, that it would be overwhelming. I think with Deanna and Lwaxana it was often played for laughs, but the reality is that all of that internal back and forth would likely drive most of us nuts.
Well done as always!
I guess it's all in what you're used to, but as a writer, I can think of nothing worse than anyone being able to peek into my unfinished, unedited thoughts ... and I really don't want to know what most other people are thinking, either. Between this and the naked weddings, Betazed is not for me. Bring on the flattering formalwear!
Date: 01 Jul 2015 02:07 Title: Amazing (Grace) - John Quigley
Ouch. JQ, you make a convincing case for abstinence, not because of any possible diseases, but because of all the emotional havoc physical intimacy like this entails.
A painfully true piece, one that strikes at one's heart. Well done.
JQ is horrified by the idea of abstinence in general, but in this case, he agrees it would have been better to keep it in his pants. There's a reason he usually sticks to sexually adventurous girls and telepaths ... he likes to have all the cards on the table, with no hidden agendas and/or expectations.
Date: 30 Jun 2015 19:03 Title: Amazing (Grace) - John Quigley
So she is memorable after all, although not for the so-called 'right' reasons.
JQ is my fave of the three. I just feel like his pain and his struggles are the most real. I hope that came out right. I like the others, but John strikes me as the most plausible and real, the one whose voice to me rings the truest.
This ficlet works extremely well, as his guilt, his caddishness, his faraway jealousy all conspire to make this a finely-etched portrait. Well done.
Thanks, jes. It's not surprising that anyone would find John the most relatable of my "big three," as he's the only one who's "only human." (Yes, Maren's human, too, but she's more than that. She's carrying a genetic legacy that skews her more in Icheb's direction than in John's. She's not normal, and probably not all that relatable to most people.) I think most people have had a moment like John had here, when they realize too late that their own issues have become deep enough to splash over the sides of their carefully constructed walls, potentially drenching or even drowning innocent bystanders.
Date: 29 Jun 2015 13:54 Title: Love and War (Fairness) - Eric Atherton
Whew. That was a lot of spitfire coming out of Atherton's mouth, but a lot of what he says isn't off base. If Icheb was genetically engineered to be that smart, that superior, he'd totally be banned (unless he pulled a Bashir and snuck by). Starfleet -- and the Federation in general -- let's things enhanced with tech get a pass (Icheb, Data) and they freak out at genetic engineering.
Atherton is an asshole, concerned only for himself (and theoretically Rachel), but he does make solid points in his soliloquy. He just doesn't bother to consider how shitty Icheb (or Seven) must feel.
Atherton told me to tell you that Icheb and Seven should feel shitty. If they'd turn the contents of their cortical arrays over to Starfleet, maybe he'd reconsider his position ever so slightly. But as long as they're playing the "my thoughts are my own, even though they're not really all my thoughts" card, he's going to keep on hating them.
(Shorter Atherton: "Haters gonna hate.")
Date: 29 Jun 2015 13:05 Title: Love and War (Fairness) - Eric Atherton
Woof, that's some major hostility - although I can see why, In the filmverse, assimilation is seen as so much worse than death that people like Hawke are just outright killed. Despite the success with Locutus, no one tries (although in all, heh, fairness, the Enterprise was outnumbered and they were desperate).
Good capture of an angry, bitter, hostile man.
Thanks. :) I think Locutus was an exception because he was designed from the start to be a different kind of drone, one more attractive to or compatible with humanity's independent nature. I'm thinking that was why it was so easy for them to remove so much of his technology, although we see in FC that it's obviously not ALL gone. But that's just fanwank on my part.
Date: 28 Jun 2015 22:03 Title: Method Three (Wisdom) - Icheb
Oh, this is bittersweet and hard to read. But it is, ultimately, his decision to make. But it seems to be getting made as a matter of weights and measures. Looking forward to seeing how you handle the rest of the prompts.
I'm hoping to hit a lot of other characters this week. Icheb just jumped out as today's victim -- ahem, subject. (Oh, never mind, that sounds just as bad.) Thanks for the review!
Date: 28 Jun 2015 22:03 Title: Method Three (Wisdom) - Icheb
That was a tough one. Hate to see Icheb break all that down mathmatically, without the benefit of hope or faith -- something with Maren provides -- and come to the cold conclusion that he has to go in order to save the woman he loves from his death.
I like your take on this, but it makes me sad.
Team I/M wishes it wasn't so.
Yeah, a bit depressing, but it's a theme and topic very much on my mind IRL and it fit the challenge. Not all of them will be this dark. (I hope ... )